Dear Editor,
In his article "God chose the Jewish people for a reason", responding to mine, Joseph Steinberg criticised my treatment of Romans 9–11. He asserts that these chapters teach that “God chose the Jewish people for a reason, and that purpose has not ended.” I appreciate his concern to uphold God's faithfulness to His promises to Israel. However, I believe his interpretation of Romans 9–11 is open to question. There is another well-established interpretation within the Reformed tradition, represented by theologians such as John Calvin and O. Palmer Robertson, which understands these chapters rather differently and is closer to my own. As some readers of Evangelicals Now may be less familiar with this approach, I would like to outline it briefly and encourage those interested to consult Calvin and Robertson for a fuller treatment.
A brief overview of Romans 9–11